I didn't know if this was a phoney one , it is like water I I went to the store where usually buy , she sprayed one of there's on paper strip , couldn't smell the scent either. I don't like paying for water only little scent when initially spray and absolutely no trace on scent after. I'm going to try a see if I can get a hold of Calvin Kline about it. The representative at the store said sometimes they change the formula. She was even surprised we couldn't smell not even a trace of scent on the paper strip nothing, so disappointing for used it for years. So many compliments before, no scent now .