Don't know if this is a dupe for Replica By The Fireplace but it smells good on it's own. It's smoky and sweet, I gave this to my husband. He kind of gets nose blind to it but I can definitely smell it on him and around him. It has great sillage, I can still get a whiff of this whenever I enter a room he's been in. Even if it's not a dupe for Replica's By The Fireplace, it smells great and for the price, this was a great blind buy!